PLAGIARISM CHECK & AI WRITING POLICY
WITHDRAWAL AND RETRACTION POLICY
JASF (Journal of Accounting and Strategic Finance) publishes manuscripts within its Aims and Scope. JASF accepts Original Research Articles, Systematic Literature Reviews, Case Studies, and Bibliometric Reviews (limited to one bibliometric review every four issues). See Manuscript Types for the requirements of each type.
Manuscripts submitted to JASF must:
Peer review.
Every manuscript is first screened by the editors for scope, plagiarism, and compliance with these guidelines. Manuscripts that pass screening are reviewed double-blind by at least two reviewers who are experts in the field, at least one of whom is external to Universitas Pembangunan Nasional “Veteran” Jawa Timur. The review process usually takes 4–16 weeks. Details are in the Review Policy. The editors may edit the style of accepted manuscripts without changing their meaning or quality.
Required submission files.
Authors must upload all three of the following files when submitting. Submissions with any file missing will be returned without review.
A cover letter is not required and does not replace the similarity report or the AI usage report. Any message for the editor can be written in the Comments for the Editor field during submission.
Questionnaires and other instruments.
Manuscripts based on primary data or experiments must include the questionnaire or experimental instrument as a supplementary file. Authors are also asked to upload the results of data processing and the original table and figure files through the JASF submission system.
Editorial decisions.
Based on the reviewers’ recommendations, the editor makes one of five decisions:
All manuscripts are checked for similarity and AI-generated writing using Turnitin before review and before publication. The similarity index must be below 15%, with no more than 1% from any single source. Manuscripts with 15–30% similarity are returned to the authors for revision, and manuscripts above 30% are rejected.
Authors who use artificial intelligence tools in preparing the manuscript must disclose this in an AI Declaration section placed before the references, in line with the Plagiarism Check and AI Writing Policy. AI tools cannot be listed as authors.
Authorship must meet the Authorship Criteria, and all competing interests must be declared under the Conflict of Interest policy. Research involving human participants must follow the Ethical Clearance policy.
The manuscript begins with the title, author identity (without academic titles), abstract, keywords, and correspondence address with e-mail.
The suggested proportion of each section is Introduction 20%, Literature Review 20%, Research Methods 10%, Results and Discussion 40%, and Conclusion 10%.
Manuscripts must be prepared using the JASF template and written in standard English.
The title must be attractive, concise, specific, and informative, and describe the whole content of the article.
Author names and affiliations appear after the title.
To keep the review double-blind, author names and affiliations must be removed from the manuscript file used for review and entered only in the submission system and on the author page.
The abstract is structured into five parts:
Keywords are meaningful words or short phrases used to index the article.
The introduction presents the background of the problem and its theoretical and practical context, the research motivation, the research gap based on the most relevant previous studies (state of the art), the research objectives and questions, and the contributions of the study. It is written in flowing paragraphs, without sub-sections, numbering, or bullet points.
Literature Review and Hypothesis Development (quantitative) or Literature Review and Focus of Study (qualitative)
This section presents the theories and previous studies used in the research. References should mainly come from reputable international journals and accredited national journals published in the last ten years, with priority given to the last five years.
For quantitative research, each hypothesis is developed from supporting theory, previous research, and logical argument, and written in this format:
H1: State the formulated hypothesis.
Hypothesis formulation policy.
Hypotheses must be grounded in theoretical propositions that explain the specific relationship between each independent variable and the dependent variable (for example, X1 → Y, X2 → Y, X3 → Y, not X1, X2, X3 → Y). JASF does not recommend simultaneous hypotheses (F-test); the F-test should be reported as a diagnostic of overall model fit in the Results section (Hair et al., 2010, 2021).
For qualitative research, the literature review is followed by the research focus, stated as a question:
RF: State the problem that represents the research focus.
The research framework or model is presented as a diagram of the relationships between variables or the focus of the study.
This section explains the research design and why it suits the research question; the population, sample, or participants and how they were selected; the data and data collection methods (for example, surveys, interviews, archival data, or experiments); the measurement of variables; the data analysis techniques; and ethical considerations such as informed consent and confidentiality. Enough detail must be given for the study to be replicated.
Results.
Present the key findings, using tables, figures, and statistical analyses where relevant, and explain the main patterns and observations.
Discussion.
Interpret the results in relation to the research objectives, hypotheses or research focus, and previous studies. Explain the implications for theory, practice, and policy, and acknowledge the limitations of the study.
The conclusion answers the research objectives, summarizes the main findings and contributions, states the theoretical, practical, and policy implications, and suggests directions for future research. It is written in flowing paragraphs, without sub-sections, numbering, or bullet points.
The following sections are placed after the conclusion and before the references.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS (optional).
Thank people or institutions who supported the research but do not meet the authorship criteria, such as those who provided data access, language editing, or technical support.
AUTHORS’ CONTRIBUTION. State each author’s contribution using their initials, preferably with the CRediT taxonomy. Example: “AAR: Conceptualization, Methodology, Writing – original draft. ST: Formal analysis, Writing – review and editing.”
AUTHORS’ INFORMATION.
Full name, e-mail address, ORCID iD, current position, research interests, and qualifications of each author.
FUNDING.
Identify all sources of funding and explain the role of the funder in the study design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, and writing. If there was no funding, state: “This research received no external funding.”
CONFLICTS OF INTEREST.
Declare all financial and non-financial competing interests, using the authors’ initials. If there are none, state: “The authors declare no conflict of interest.”
AVAILABILITY OF DATA AND MATERIALS.
Explain where and how the data and materials supporting the findings can be accessed, or why they cannot be shared.
AI DECLARATION (if applicable).
Name the AI tool used and its purpose, and confirm that the authors take full responsibility for the content. This is not required for basic tools that check grammar, spelling, or references.
References follow the APA Style 7th edition and must be managed with a reference manager such as Mendeley, Zotero, EndNote, or RefWorks.
Mathematical formulas are written with Microsoft Equation or a similar tool, numbered, and their source is cited.
Journal article
Author, A. A., Author, B. B., & Author, C. C. (Year). Title of the article in sentence case. Journal Name in Title Case, Volume(Issue), first page–last page. https://doi.org/xxxxx
Journal article in Indonesian (give an English translation of the title in square brackets)
Author, A. A. (Year). Judul artikel dalam bahasa Indonesia [Title of the article in English]. Nama Jurnal, Volume(Issue), pages. https://doi.org/xxxxx
Book
Author, A. A. (Year). Title of the book (2nd ed.). Publisher.
Chapter in an edited book
Author, A. A. (Year). Title of the chapter. In E. E. Editor (Ed.), Title of the book (pp. xx–xx). Publisher.
Conference paper
Author, A. A. (Year, Month Day–Day). Title of the paper [Paper presentation]. Name of the Conference, City, Country. https://xxxxx
Thesis or dissertation
Author, A. A. (Year). Title of the thesis [Master’s thesis or Doctoral dissertation, Name of University]. Repository name. https://xxxxx
Government regulation or report
Name of Agency. (Year). Title of the regulation or report (Report No. xxx). https://xxxxx